Scenario Planning: A Tool for the Times

by

As we all make our best efforts, both personally and professionally, to move forward – despite the challenges we are facing with the pandemic and the economy – I’ve found myself thinking more and more about the value of scenario planning. I know it is tempting to just freeze in place and to “wait and see” how things pan out before taking on anything strategic. The changes that are underway feel so significant and the ambiguity of what’s ahead makes it hard to know what actions to take. But, scenario planning can help bring strategic foresight to the never-ending uncertainty. That makes it one of the most important and pragmatic things you can do to help prepare your business for the unknown odyssey that this pandemic is taking us on.

We used scenario planning at Thought Ensemble over the last few weeks and it was a very helpful perspective to bring into our quarterly strategic planning. It helped us open up our minds to what’s potentially ahead of us and get clear on what we need to take on next. While we still don’t know what the pandemic and associated economic challenges mean for us long term, we are clearer and more confident about what actions we can be taking in the next couple of months. I’ll publish another blog about our experience using scenario planning at Thought Ensemble soon, but in the meantime, let’s go over the basics.

A Very Brief Overview of Scenario Planning

I’m not going to dive super deep into the history or “how-to” of scenario planning, but if that is something you are interested in here is a Wikipedia article that outlines the basics and here is an HBR article that goes even deeper into the history.

Scenario Planning was popularized by Shell in the 1960s as a way to preemptively develop business strategies that could address uncertain futures. It has been used effectively across many businesses, so there are countless variations on exactly how to do it.

In my opinion, it is a more helpful practice once your basic business needs are under control. With COVID-19, many businesses are fighting just to stay afloat and having to make extremely difficult decisions to do so. There are better tools for addressing those types of situations, but for those who are fortunate enough to not be completely consumed by firefighting, scenario planning is a great way to get more strategic.

Scenario Planning Step by Step

If you search the web for “scenario planning” you’ll find a lot of different ideas on how exactly to do it, but below is a very quick overview of the process that we have found works well for us:

  1. Start by listing all the future uncertainties that could impact your business
  2. Pick the top two uncertainties that, when combined, are most likely to cause the greatest disruption to your business – For example, how severe the pandemic will be and how heavily the economy will be impacted
  3. Plot the extremes of those two uncertainties on a 2×2 matrix
  4. Describe each of the quadrants as a plausible future scenario using a few sentences or bullet points
  5. Create an easy to reference name for each scenario

At this point, your scenarios are drafted. Now you can use them for strategic planning by considering:

  • How each scenario impacts your customers and other external stakeholders
  • How you could shine in each scenario
  • What strategic actions you might want to take in each scenario

Scenario planning is not intended to be a decision tree, where you develop a plan for each scenario and then pull it out and use it like a playbook once that scenario happens. The actual future is unpredictable and will likely involve a combination of elements from a variety of the scenarios you develop. The purpose of scenario planning is to help open your mind to these possibilities and to inform strategic planning based on that.

Some Additional Thoughts and Resources

If you think all this sounds interesting and want to read more, I have a few resources here that might be helpful.

First, one of my friends sent me this link from Kantar about a month ago with the tag, “This is right up your alley.” Sure enough, I devoured it. It was perfect timing – we were just starting to think about doing a scenario planning exercise for Thought Ensemble. I knew I wanted to use a framework like this but hadn’t seen scenarios specific to COVID-19 yet that I liked. I like these a lot with the caveat that they really have three dimensions in here (versus the typical two), and neither of their two approaches aligned quite right with our business because Kantar has a People (consumer) point of view, as well as an Institutional point of view. But, for B2C companies, the People angle is very interesting.

Second, Deloitte and Salesforce also just published a collaborative effort they did on scenario planning. Their dimensions were a little different – they looked at severity of the pandemic versus collaboration within, and between, countries. They also didn’t use a pure 2×2 view, but the outcome is similar.

Third, if you agree with the importance of running through your own scenario planning session, but find yourself getting flustered at the idea of trying to wrangle and manage all the necessary people and resources virtually, then check out my colleague Cassandra Rambo’s blog: 3 Reasons Why You Should Host a Virtual Workshop. In it, Cassandra walks through the benefits of holding these types of sessions virtually and how to capitalize on them. You might be as surprised as we were to find out just how effective virtual workshops can be.

As you can probably tell, I absolutely love this topic. So, if you have any questions, thoughts, or just need a resource to bounce ideas off of, feel free to reach out as I love to talk scenario planning!

READ MORE

Thought Ensemble’s Purpose — Inspired in 2020

Thought Ensemble’s Purpose — Inspired in 2020

I recently wrote about how company purpose is being tested and inspired by all the events of 2020. This topic is very real for us at Thought Ensemble. We’ve been thinking a lot about what really matters as we’ve navigated the...

read more
How 2020 Is Testing and Inspiring Corporate Purpose

How 2020 Is Testing and Inspiring Corporate Purpose

In August 2019, the Business Roundtable rewrote their statement of corporate purpose. I followed this with significant interest being that I have never forgotten the debates about corporate purpose in business school almost two decades ago. We were taught that the...

read more
Why Purpose-Driven Organizations May Struggle With Change

Why Purpose-Driven Organizations May Struggle With Change

I love working with companies who really want to make a difference, beyond just making money for their shareholders. I mean, making money is fun and all, but it is even more rewarding to join in on a just cause. Plus, as this HBR article explains, companies who have...

read more
Is a Good Career Accidental or Intentional?

Is a Good Career Accidental or Intentional?

I accepted a Zoom call with a college senior recently. He wanted to understand how I had navigated my career to reach the position I’m in today. He had looked at my LinkedIn profile and assumed I had made a series of calculated career moves to get to my current...

read more
How Do We Make a Difference?

How Do We Make a Difference?

Leadership in 2020 Everyone is saying that nothing is going to be the same again after 2020. I’d add being a business leader to that list. I’ll never be the same. In the first few months of the year, I was already working on being more expressive with my opinions and...

read more
How We Are Using Scenario Planning to Navigate COVID-19

How We Are Using Scenario Planning to Navigate COVID-19

About six weeks ago, I couldn’t stop thinking about the scenarios that we as a company might be navigating later in the year and in the coming years. Back then (which seems like forever ago), we were in the midst of more immediate reactions to the current pandemic,...

read more
Homeschooling Take 2

Homeschooling Take 2

A couple weeks back, I wrote in my post about homeschooling challenges that I’d post again once things got better. We have by no means figured it all out yet, but we have settled into a new routine. Our kids’ school has been trying to evolve to support family needs,...

read more
Thoughts for Colleagues of Parents Running Homeschools

Thoughts for Colleagues of Parents Running Homeschools

I love working from home. I love my kids. However, I do NOT love working from home while also homeschooling my kids. The last few days have been a huge challenge. I’m exhausted. I feel like I’m not doing enough. I feel like I should read this article again. And then,...

read more
Tips from a Veteran of Working Remotely

Tips from a Veteran of Working Remotely

Before I go into this post, I just want to acknowledge that I realize there are many people out there who do not have the option of working remotely. For an overwhelming number of people, their incomes and livelihoods are dependent on being able to go into their...

read more